Chapel Hill Nc Obituaries, Articles L

In effect, this finding was a determination that Furstenfeld's testimony was not as credible as Pepin's evidence. Furstenfeld contends, restated, that the district court had no authority to order him to obtain the records from the health care providers for eventual production to Pepin and therefore erred in doing so. [4]Modification of a dissolution decree is a matter entrusted to the discretion of the trial court, whose order is reviewed de novo on the record, and which will be affirmed absent an abuse of discretion. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. Justin Furstenfeld is known for Step Up 3D (2010), American Wedding (2003) and NCIS (2003). Justin Furstenfeld was born on the 14th of December, 1975. 4. All rights reserved. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. The birth date was listed as 1979-06-11. Furstenfeld cannot show the admission of this letter into evidence prejudiced a substantial right because the district court did not rely upon this exhibit in ruling upon Pepin's motion. Furstenfeld also asserts that the district court should not have received the proposed stipulation into evidence because it was not relevant. Later that day, Catlett received an e-mail from Poppe's assistant which stated that it included the stipulation for modification of decree based on the agreement reached that morning. The district court did not abuse its discretion when it determined this exhibit was relevant. Justin has been sober for four years, and when he met his wife he was surprised that she had never heard of the band. How long has Justin Furstenfeld been clean? He also filed a counterclaim alleging Pepin had interfered with his exercise of his parenting time and relationship with the child, and requesting that sole custody be awarded to him. The 13-year-old gave her first-ever interview in December 2020 with the 519 magazine. The purpose of an appellant's reply brief is to respond to the arguments the appellee has advanced against the errors assigned in the appellant's initial brief. Assuming without deciding that an ancillary discovery proceeding was a special proceeding, we concluded that the discovery order did not affect a substantial right because any error could be effectively vindicated in an appeal from the final judgment.18. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Id. Party Name. justin and lisa furstenfeld wedding. PROOF I'd like to introduce everyone to my oldest daughter . In December 2010, Pepin and Furstenfeld's marriage was dissolved pursuant to a decree of dissolution. During the ensuing litigation, Pepin and her former husband, Justin S. Furstenfeld, engaged in settlement negotiations and Pepin believed an oral settlement agreement had been reached. Justin Furstenfeld was born in Houston, TX on December 14, 1975. - ?) After determining it would allow Catlett to testify, the court permitted Furstenfeld to obtain other counsel. In other words, he concludes an attorney's testimony is not permitted under the statute. See id. Furstenfeld perfected a timely appeal from this order, which we moved to our docket on our own motion pursuant to our authority to regulate the caseloads of the appellate courts of this state.1. Jon Bon Jovis net worth is $410 million Jon Bon Jovi made most of his fortune by being the frontman for Bon Jovi, one of the bestselling rock groups of all time. Truffle hunter, beekeeper, winemaker. On April 2, 2016, Furstenfeld and his wife had a son, Gunner Black. Tools justin and lisa furstenfeld wedding. The magazine was in a phone interview with the lead vocalist of Blue October when her daughter was asked to join in. He was previously married to Lisa Pepin. The bands biggest hits, Hate Me and Into the Ocean, are harrowing chronicles of addiction and trauma. Lisa is a high school graduate. According to Furstenfeld, the court's decision to allow Catlett's testimony and then subsequently rely on that testimony to sustain Pepin's motion rigged the game in Pepin's favor. One of the users extended her gratitude to Sarah for being with Justin on his road to recovery. But the band's new album . Catlett's testimony was material to the issues being litigated. Id. It was the tenth studio album by the Texas-based band Blue October, which was released on October 23. The birth date was listed as 1979-06-11. Court Number. For an appellate court to acquire jurisdiction of an appeal, there must be a final order entered by the tribunal from which the appeal is taken.4 The three types of final orders which may be reviewed on appeal are (1) an order which affects a substantial right and which determines the action and prevents a judgment, (2) an order affecting a substantial right made during a special proceeding, and (3) an order affecting a substantial right made on summary application in an action after judgment is rendered.5 The order in this matter did not determine the action and prevent a judgment, and it was not made on summary application in an action after judgment was rendered. Although the district court did not cite this rule as authority for its order, we conclude that it can be fairly characterized as an order compelling discovery. Atty. Blue Reed was born in 2007 to Justin and Lisa Pepin. He acknowledges as much at the end of each such statement by noting the assertion is not in the record. As has long been the case, appellate courts do not generally consider arguments and theories raised for the first time on appeal. R. 402, Neb.Rev.Stat. 124, 760 N.W.2d 28 (2009). The court overruled the objection and permitted Pepin to question Catlett on a limited basis. The comment section was particularly filled with warm wishes and regards for the mother. The film also stars Dermot Mulroney, Rourke, Dolph Lundgren and Tracy Perez. . A successful 35+ year run, 19 top ten singles, 15 million albums sold, four Grammy nominations There are bands with lesser credentials (and, frankly, not as enjoyable) as Goo Goo Dolls inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. She shares beautiful moments with her children, husband, and pet cat on social media. 279, 808 N.W.2d 855 (2012). We separately analyze each exhibit below. The mother posted her first Instagram photo on November 21, 2012, which saw Justin carrying his newly born daughter. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Ct. R. App. 15. At the hearing, Furstenfeld argued against Pepin's motion to enforce on the ground that Catlett did not have authority to enter into the settlement agreement. The stipulation further stated that the minor child's image would not be used for any purpose by Furstenfeld's band and that the child would not attend any of Furstenfeld's concerts without Pepin's prior approval. He's been in the band since forming it with brother Jeremy and on the latest album they're joined by a new generation of Furstenfelds. We would like to show you a description here but the site won't allow us. Furstenfeld elected to represent himself. There is no dispute that Pepin was offering the statements in the e-mail against Furstenfeld. We therefore focus our inquiry on whether it affected a substantial right and was made during a special proceeding. 43 year old female; Lincoln, NE San Marcos, TX Beverly Hills, CA; Heidi Dawn Bautch Sarah Elise Conner Justin Steward Furstenfeld Michelle L Jedlicka More People; Get Your Report Page of 1 Select the first letter of the last name of the person you are searching for . Having reviewed the record, we conclude the district court did not clearly err in determining that Furstenfeld granted Catlett the necessary authority to settle the modification action. Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site! We reject this argument. Justin Steward Furstenfeld is a rock singer and the lead vocalist of the Houston-based rock band Blue October. Its nice to be going out there and just promoting happiness and peace. Other provisions included within the stipulation provided that Furstenfeld would pay $2,500 toward Pepin's attorney fees, that certain orders to show cause would be vacated, and that the parties would not make disparaging or derogatory comments about the other through various means of communication. Furstenfeld's arguments relating to the court's receipt of this exhibit in evidence are without merit. Justin Furstenfeld * Blue October. Email: ssmtoffice@gmail.com / ssmtpmu@gmail.com / ssmtjobs@gmail.com Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. By Justin and Sarah hold their daughter Sayde together to take a quick family photo in 2014 ( Source : instagram ). Lisa Pepin (@lisapepin) Instagram photos and videos lisapepin 5,243 posts 5,491 followers following Lisa Pepin American in Provence. Battles with Bipolar Disorder and depression. Previously, he was married to Lisa Pepin, with who he has a daughter, Blue Reed Furstenfeld. Melanie M. v. Winterer, 290 Neb. 27801(4)(b) (Reissue 2008), provides in relevant part that a statement is not hearsay if, [t]he statement is offered against a party and is (i) his own statement, in either his individual or a representative capacity, (iii) a statement by a person authorized by him to make a statement concerning the subject, or (iv) a statement by his agent or servant within the scope of his agency or employment. View agent, publicist, legal and company contact details on IMDbPro. It's a picturesque life. Lisa is a high school graduate. A jurisdictional question which does not involve a factual dispute is determined by an appellate court as a matter of law, which requires the appellate court to reach a conclusion independent of the lower court's decision.2. He broadly asserts that there is no legal significance to any agreement that purports to establish or modify a child support obligation. Lisa B. Pepin filed a complaint to modify the parenting time and support provisions of a decree of dissolution. Justin challenges the court's award to Lisa B. Pepin of $5,000 in temporary attorney fees. Even if we generously assume that this argument somehow relates to one of the four errors Furstenfeld has assigned, this issue was not presented to the district court at the hearing on the motion to enforce. This reflects the general procedure set forth in 6334 of the discovery rules for obtaining discovery in the form of documents from an opposing party. I remember thinking, as we were driving home, that he would be a very interesting person to one day have a conversation with. Sarah Furstenfeld celebrates her birthday on the 11th day of February. He was previously married to Lisa Pepin. Furstenfeld appeals from that order. He was previously married to Lisa Pepin. Justin and Sarah are parents of three kids Blue Reed, Sayde Belle, and Gunner Black. The order does not affect a substantial right, and it is therefore not appealable. 213, 846 N.W.2d 626 (2014). We have closely reviewed these cases and determine that neither case squarely addresses the issue of whether an attorney's testimony as a witness satisfies the statutory language cited above. We find no merit to Furstenfeld's arguments that his testimony that Catlett was not authorized to make any statements on his behalf was sufficient to rebut the presumption of such authority. Blue October is an alternative rock band that came from Houston, Texas. Lisa Pepin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". lisa pepin blue furstenfeldneon vs led power consumption. Stipulated agreements of child support are required to be reviewed against the guidelines. Justin and Sarah Furstenfeld had their wedding on July 25 2012. A substantial right is an essential legal right, not a mere technical right.8 A substantial right is affected if the order affects the subject matter of the litigation, such as diminishing a claim or defense that was available to an appellant prior to the order from which an appeal is taken.9 Here, although the order at issue does not cite to any specific provision of the Nebraska Court Rules of Discovery in Civil Cases,10 it is clear that it was entered in response to a dispute which arose in the course of pretrial discovery. We will not address this argument because it was not raised in Furstenfeld's initial brief. The court also found that because the two health care providers were beyond its jurisdiction, there was no mechanism for Pepin to obtain the records other than through suitable waivers and/or releases executed by Furstenfeld. Justin S. Furstenfeld, Appellant, v. Lisa B. Pepin, Appellee. Musician's ex-wife offended by new album. After reaching this agreement, Poppe and Catlett jointly contacted the district court judge to notify the court of the agreement and to remove the matter from the court's trial calendar. In contrast, allowing an interlocutory appeal in this case promotes significant delay in the guardianship proceedings and the ultimate resolution of [the minor child's] custody.14, We applied the same reasoning in Steven S. v. Mary S.,15 a proceeding to modify the child custody provisions of a decree of dissolution. To assist the court and not as a rebuttable presumption, the court may use the amount at $15,000 plus: 10 percent of net income above $15,000 for one, two, and three children; 12 percent of net income above $15,000 for four children; 13 percent of net income for five children; and 14 percent of net income for six children. Justin Furstenfeld wife Sarah Furstnefeld is a famous social media personality. 276, 847 N.W.2d 283 (2014). After the singer separated from Lisa, he took custody of his daughter. Justin S. Furstenfeld, Appellant, v. Lisa B. Pepin, Appellee. Co., 1 Neb.App. Cause Lists. Discovery orders are not generally subject to interlocutory appeal because the underlying litigation is ongoing and the discovery order is not considered final.11 However, if the discovery order affects a substantial right and was made in a special proceeding, it is appealable.12. [15]We find this exhibit to be relevant to the determination of this action. In fact, this exhibit is not even mentioned in the court's order. R. 801(4)(b), Neb.Rev.Stat. Justin Furstenfeld (Courtesy of PFA Entertainment Media and Marketing) Alternative rock band Blue October's newest release, "Any Man in America," has been . In his first assigned error, Furstenfeld attacks the district court's evidentiary rulings regarding three separate exhibits. Ten-year-old Sayde is the elder daughter of Gunner Black. Sutton v. Killham, 285 Neb. See Luethke v. Suhr, supra. 152, 794 N.W.2d 685 (2011). [68]In proceedings where the Nebraska Evidence Rules apply, the admissibility of evidence is controlled by the Nebraska Evidence Rules; judicial discretion is involved only when the rules make discretion a factor in determining admissibility. . Id. P. 2-102(C . Sarah is a celebrity on Instagram, followed by 18.5K people. 764, 862 N.W.2d 76 (2015). Blue Reed Furstenfeld is the first child of Justin and Lisa Pepin. Sayde became a sister in 2016 when Sarah gave birth to her second child. FIR Number. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. What was the lead singer of Blue October addicted to? Formerly of. 27402 (Reissue 2008), all relevant evidence is admissible unless there is some specific constitutional or statutory reason to exclude such evidence. A trial court has the discretion to determine the relevancy and admissibility of evidence, and such determinations will not be disturbed on appeal unless they constitute an abuse of that discretion. Blue Reed Furstenfeld is the first child of Justin and Lisa Pepin. Mr. Furstenfeld, 37, who formed Blue October in Houston in 1995 with his brother Jeremy and his high school friend Ryan Delahoussaye, speaks openly about his past. He has been married to Sarah Furstenfeld since July 25, 2012. The district court did not err when it concluded that Pepin and Furstenfeld had reached a settlement agreement. Justin and his daughter Sayde enjoy spending time with Gunner Black and engage in many joyous activities every time they get together. justin furstenfeld tattoos. Bibek Pandey After receiving his law degree from the University of Maine School of Law, John started his career at a large law firm in Portland. Furstenfeld has a daughter named Blue, who was born in . The court also specified in its order that it did not find Furstenfeld's testimony determinative on the issue of whether Catlett had been given authority to settle. On October 22, 2009, Blue October announced that the rest of their tour had been canceled due to Furstenfeld suffering a severe mental anxiety attack. The ability to eat anything without gaining weight. Order Date. The burden of proof of such want of authority is upon the party asserting the same. He has been married to Sarah Furstenfeld since July 25, 2012. Justin is the lead vocalist and guitarist of the music band. Is the lead singer of the band Blue October. Furstenfeld highlights the fact that Pepin filed numerous motions after her motion to enforce which included an amended motion to take Furstenfeld's deposition, a motion to release Furstenfeld's medical records, a motion regarding parenting time during Christmas 2013, and a motion to suspend Furstenfeld's parenting time. In May 2017, the singer took his children to the San Diego Zoo in San Diego, California, for a visit. In a proceeding commenced by Lisa B. Pepin to modify the child custody and support provisions of a decree of dissolution, the district court for Lancaster County ordered Pepin s former spouse, Justin S. Furstenfeld, to obtain certain medical records from two health care providers located outside Nebraska. The party moving to disqualify an opposing attorney bears the burden of establishing that the attorney's testimony will be necessary. Lisa Brooke Pepin Furstenfeld. Id. The 47-year-old is married to Sarah Furstenfeld after his divorce from Lisa Pepin. [2325]Nebraska law is clear that the decision to settle a lawsuit belongs to the client; because the client bears the risk when settling or refusing to settle a dispute, it is the client, not the lawyer, who should assess whether the risk is acceptable. The plain language of 7107 supports such a result. It was recorded in October 1997, at Sound Arts Studio in Houston, Texas. On April 4 2016, Sarah shared the first photo of her newly born son Gunner Black on her Instagram and announced his arrival in the world. FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. Justin was married to Lisa Pepin for the first time. We further noted: Although a mental examination, once ordered and performed, cannot be undone, we are not convinced that any harm caused by waiting to appeal the order until after final judgment is sufficient to warrant an interlocutory appeal. The evidence at the hearing established that Furstenfeld and Catlett were in telephone communication during the negotiations on May 16, 2012. Instrument (s) Vocals, guitar. It will cost about $1,000 to $2,000 to acquire one of these 'Gentle Giants.'. On July 28, 2012, they were married in a private ceremony in Wimberley, Texas. The stipulation for modification of decree provided, in pertinent part, that Furstenfeld's child support obligation would increase to $3,000 per month commencing June 1, 2012. The child support calculation worksheets attached to the court's order are consistent with the guidelines, and we can find no abuse of discretion in the court's adoption of the stipulation and the child support worksheets. Either wrote or co-wrote all of Blue October's songs. [17]For the sake of argument, we will assume that Furstenfeld correctly argues that the court's receipt of this exhibit constituted error on the basis of relevance. Yes, John and Robby will be at Jacobs Pavilion on August 10. To have a settlement agreement, there must be a definite offer and an unconditional acceptance. On the issue of an attorney's authority to make statements on behalf of a client, the Nebraska Supreme Court has held that when an attorney appears in a cause, there is a presumption that the attorney has authority and that presumption continues until the want of such authority is established. On August 29, 2014, the court signed and filed the order Poppe prepared. 52 years old North Smithfield, Rhode Island, 2896. Justin Furstenfeld on Blue October's 2006 Hit "Hate Me" Read More The post The Why & The How: Justin . Where the Nebraska Evidence Rules commit the evidentiary question at issue to the discretion of the trial court, an appellate court reviews the admissibility of evidence for an abuse of discretion. Catlett confirmed that settlement negotiations ensued, an agreement was reached, and he and Poppe contacted the court to inform it that the matter had been settled. The couple is living together with their kids in Texas. 553, 805 N.W.2d 68 (2011); Tolbert v. Jamison, 281 Neb. Has two daughters. Sarah decided to capture a moment of him every month of her son and shared the pictures on Instagram. They have two children. Id. Family (1) Spouse Sarah Furstenfeld ( 25 July 2012 present) (2 children) I came back the next day with a song written. 4. Neither party will need to appear since we're not changing custody or parenting time. The order recites that Furstenfeld's treatment at the two out-of-state facilities became known in the course of discovery and that Pepin had served a request for production of the medical records, to which Furstenfeld had responded that the records were not in his possession or control. 530, 861 N.W.2d 113 (2015). justin and lisa furstenfeld wedding justin and lisa furstenfeld wedding. He has been married to Sarah Furstenfeld since July 25, 2012. 505, 650 N.W.2d 220 (2002). Top titles Latest Filmography 2022 2020 2016 2010 2003 1999 Connections Norry Niven Sophia Bui King Hollis Genres Pepin-Furstenfeld Case Number A-14-0814 Call Date June 10, 2015 Case Time 1:00 PM Case Audio Download Audio Case Summary A-14-0814, Justin S. Furstenfeld (Appellant) v. Lisa B. Pepin-Furstenfeld District Court for Lancaster County, District Judge John A. Colborn Attorney for Appellant: Matt Catlett The court determined that this agreement unconditionally resolved all material terms of the dispute. 133, 710 N.W.2d 312 (2006). 682, 619 N.W.2d 230 (2000). He asserts that Catlett never made such a statement during the hearing. 1981 kawasaki kz750 ltd specs They have two children. During the ensuing litigation, Pepin and her former husband, Justin S. Furstenfeld, engaged in settlement negotiations and Pepin believed an oral settlement agreement had been reached. Lisa Pepin (Lisa dawn Adams) See Photos. Lisa Pepin. Blue made her debut as a singer with the 2020 album 'This Is What I Live For.' My Name is. In re Guardianship of Sophia M., supra note 11. The court ordered Furstenfeld to execute the documents necessary to obtain the records from the facilities and to have the records delivered to his attorney, who was then required to review them and either provide copies to Pepin or file an appropriate objection with the court. Ct. R. Disc. Neb. Has partnered with the ACFC (American Coalition for Fathers and Children). Mar 4, 2018 - Justin Furstenfeld Lisa Pepin | Now every man in America take back your control." -Blue October. The bands name was inspired by a stay in a hospital that lead vocalist Justin Furstenfeld had to make. What is the Goo Goo Dolls most famous song? Though Furstenfeld didnt talk a lot about God that night, his faith was clear in how he expressed his passion for living and the glory of redemption. Catlett further testified at the hearing that he did not have any reason to believe the proposed stipulation was not the same document he reviewed 2 years prior to the hearing. 1, 825 N.W.2d 188 (2013). When she started a relationship with the rock singer, he was dealing with depression. Lisa Bro Pepin-Furstenfeld Lisa Brook Pepin-Furstenfeld L Pepin Lisa B Pepin. It does not store any personal data. 220, 491 N.W.2d 368 (1992). Steven S. v. Mary S., supra note 2. About Us; Staff; Camps; Scuba. Poppe offered this letter as evidence at the hearing and informed the court that he was offering this letter to reflect that he had attempted to avoid calling Catlett as a witness, but had no other choice. On cross-examination, Catlett stated that his client had not given him the right to sign off on anything. Advocate Name. The band's biggest hits, "Hate Me" and "Into the Ocean," are harrowing chronicles of. Catlett acknowledged that on May 15, 2012, he sent an e-mail to Poppe which contained the terms on which Furstenfeld offered to settle the case. The Texan started his career as a rock singer at the age of 13 and formed his first music band, The Last Kiss, in 1989 while in College. Justin and Lisa are the parents of Blue Reed Furstenfeld. Record producer, lyricist, and lead singer of the alternative rock band Blue October who released the single "Hate Me." He toured with Stephenie Meyer for a Twilight series concert and book tour. justin and lisa furstenfeld wedding. The couple has been together for more than a decade. See Photos. 542, 861 N.W.2d 367 (2015). In a proceeding commenced by Lisa B. Pepin to modify the child custody and support provisions of a decree of dissolution, the district court for Lancaster County ordered Pepin's former spouse, Justin S. Furstenfeld, to obtain certain medical records from two health care providers located outside Nebraska. You may also know she as Furstenfeld Lisa Pepin, Lisa Pepin Furstenfeld, Lisa Pepin, Lisa P Pepin, Lisa Tepin, L Pepin. He has been married to Sarah Furstenfeld since 25 July 2012. "It's been rough, dude," he told Noisecreep. 206, 794 N.W.2d 877 (2011). My Funny Profile. In addition to the previous errors discussed above, Furstenfeld also argues there was not sufficient evidence for the district court to sustain Pepin's motion to enforce the agreement. They have two children. In response, Pepin states that this discrepancy in date was clearly recognized by the parties at the hearing and that Furstenfeld did not raise this discrepancy as an issue. Features & Details Category Wedding Project Option: Standard Landscape, 108 in, 2520 cm # of Pages: 322 Publish Date: Mar 10, 2008 Tags Cabo San Lucas, Los Cabos, Lisa and Justin, Wedding He also became a member of the four-piece rock band Harvard of the South in 2014. However, in his brief, Furstenfeld argues that this statement should have no bearing on the issue of whether Catlett actually had authority to make statements on his behalf. The new Blue October album is going to be called 'Any Man in America' because in the past two years I've learned that men in this country get screwed by the judicial system. Log in or sign up for Facebook to connect with friends, family and people you know. Furstenfeld also claims this e-mail is hearsay because Catlett did not have authority to act as his agent and make statements on his behalf. During the ensuing litigation, Pepin and her former husband, Justin S. Furstenfeld, engaged in settlement negotiations and Pepin believed an oral settlement agreement had been reached. Sayde Belle was four years old when Gunner Black arrived. The songs "Jump Rope", "Blue Skies", and "Blue Does" from the 2009 album "Approaching Normal" were written for Blue. The Answers is the first album by Blue October. Justins unique vocals translated well into a live setting. | His wife is Sarah Furstenfeld (m. 2012) Justin Furstenfeld Net Worth His net worth has been growing significantly in 2020-2021. Pepin alleged that the records were necessary for the upcoming trial on parenting time and that the health care providers would not release the records without a court order or an authorization signed by Furstenfeld. Post author By ; Post date cheap apartments for rent in claremont, ca; can you wash bissell crosswave brush in the washing machine . 619, 522 N.W.2d 155 (1994). This picture alone is proof that second chances are possible if you follow through with your word of stepping up and doing the next right thing. He is the lead vocalist, guitarist, and lyricist of rock band Blue October. He was previously married to Lisa Pepin. While these decrees are not in our record, the district court's order in this proceeding indicates that the initial decree approved the parties' property settlement, custody agreement, and support agreement and that the amended decree corrected errors in two provisions of this agreement. Pepin asserted that she and Furstenfeld reached a settlement agreement; Furstenfeld denied that an agreement had been reached and also argued that Catlett never had authority to enter into a settlement agreement or engage in settlement negotiations. The Blue October played together so well and sounded good live. He focuses his discussion on the fact that Pepin could not produce any direct evidence to establish that Furstenfeld had given Catlett express authority to enter into the settlement agreement.